The euphoria in Berlin was palpable. After sixteen years of Orbán, finally a young, German-speaking beacon of hope who was supposed to end the conflict and bring Hungary back into Europe’s embrace. Friedrich Merz rolled out the red carpet, and the Konrad Adenauer Foundation made the new Hungarian prime minister the first head of government ever to be allowed to deliver the prestigious Europe speech. On November 9, the anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall, Péter Magyar was supposed to build bridges. Instead, he settled scores.
He spoke almost flawless German and recalled that Hungary had knocked out the first stone from the wall in 1989. Then came the reckoning. He divided Europe’s political class into three categories: ivory-tower dwellers who, driven by ideology and out of touch with ordinary people, divide society. False critics of the system who exploit frustration and fear and constantly manufacture new enemies. And forces that pose as patriots but divide Europe in the interests of outside powers. This is not a diplomatic platitude. This is a description of the Berlin and Brussels establishment, which sees itself as the solution and citizens as the problem.
Magyar called for a third kind of politics: democratic criticism of the system backed by a broad majority. A Hungary that works and puts people first must also make a Europe that works and puts people first possible. The political leaders of the member states know better what their citizens need than anyone sitting at a desk in Brussels. Affordable energy instead of ideological dictates. Competitiveness instead of Draghi reports that nobody implements. And on migration, a clear message: it was unacceptable for Hungary to pay a million euros in fines every day for protecting the external borders while other countries offloaded the consequences. As long as he was in office, he would defend the borders. This is not a return to Orbán. This is a continuation of what Hungarian voters want.
The next day, speaking to Merz, he repeated his criticism of Ukraine’s preferential treatment, insisted on a merit-based enlargement process and rejected linking the EU budget to further support for Ukraine. The tone was more conciliatory, but the substance remained. The German hope that a new face would automatically mean a different policy on the core issues of migration, Ukraine and sovereignty has proved to be wishful thinking. Hungarian society was tired of confrontation, not of pursuing its own interests.
What is being sold in Berlin as a disappointment is, in truth, the bitter realization that being close to citizens and protecting borders are not far-right special requests, but majority positions that Germany would rather pathologize. Magyar held a mirror up to the elites: Wake up, Europe. Return to the people. The fact that the Konrad Adenauer Foundation and the German chancellor had to sit through this speech shows how far reality is from their own wishful thinking. Anyone who still believes that Hungarian voters can be re-educated through charm and concessions has not learned the lesson. The reckoning was unsparing. And it does not apply only to Budapest.