Piketty o ideologiji “majhne vlade” kot recepta za uspeh

Jasno je, da nobeni državi ni uspelo postati razvita brez naložb v infrastrukturo, javno šolstvo in institucionalni sistem (sodstvo, policija, administracija itd.). Nobeni držabi ni uspelo z “majhno vlado” (merjeno kot % pobranih davkov glede na BDP), kajti sicer ne bi mogla financirati zgornjih javnih naložb in sistema. Thomas Piketty pravi, da gre pri zahtevah (konzervativcev) za “majhno vlado” seveda zgolj za ideologijo.

There are many different ways to organize capitalism. If you take the European Union, you have twenty-eight countries, so you have twenty-eight different ways to organize capitalism. If you look at Sweden or Denmark, at one extreme, you have 50 percent of the GDP in tax revenue and public services, and these are the richest countries in the European Union.

If you take the poorest countries in the European Union, like Bulgaria or Romania, they have very small government, 20 percent of GDP in tax revenue. So if it was enough to have a small government to be rich, then Romania and Bulgaria would be richer than Sweden and Denmark. What you can infer from this—it’s not that you always want a bigger government—depends on what you do with the money. If you use the public revenue to have efficient public services, to invest in universities, to invest in a system like Denmark and Sweden, then I think a big government is certainly not bad. In the case of France, where the public services, the public sector, are not as well organized as in Sweden, or Denmark, so then I think a big government is not necessarily good—it depends. If you have a big government, and it’s completely corrupt, then of course that’s very bad. So it all depends.

The evidence we have from history is that there is no country that has become rich with minimal government. This just does not exist. If you take rich countries today, whether in the United States, in Europe, or in Japan, the size of their government is between 30 and 50 percent of GDP in tax revenue. There’s no country that has become rich with a government that has 10 percent of GDP. When we are taking India, or sub-Saharan Africa, and saying you should just have minimal government and everything should work fine, you know, this is ideology because this is not a recipe that rich countries would apply to themselves.

Vir: Thomas Piketty

2 responses

  1. Ta je sploh najboljša. Majhne vlade so majhne zato, ker so tudi na čelu skorumpiranih družb kjer se seveda ne pobira in ne porablja dajatev kot je treba. Kak Afganistan je prava zgodba o uspehu, na vrhu majhna vlada in svobodni trg opija, v kolikor se zahodni križarji, ki sicer pridigajo svobodo, ne vmešavajo in te “krasne” svobode ne omejujejo 🙂

%d bloggers like this: